Skilled Nursing Payment Changes Looming

Original story posted on: January 30, 2019

  • Product Headline: Avoid Denials: Learn How to Crosswalk from Acute Care to SNF
  • Product Image: Product Image
  • Product Description:


CMS to launch new Patient-Driven Payment Model October 2019.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) was tired of paying too much for care in nursing homes. They were tired of fighting with lawyers and consultants driving up payments and gaming the system. 

CMS is finally replacing the Resource Utilization Group System (or “RUGs”) with a new system: The Patient-Driven Payment Model, or “PDPM.” The new system becomes effective on Oct. 1, 2019. 

Skilled nursing homes are paid a per-diem payment by Medicare under the RUG system. The new PDPM system is also a per-diem payment method.

The RUG payment model was largely driven by the number of minutes of physical, occupational, and speech therapy provided, as well as a score for the assistance the patient required to perform activities of daily living (or “ADL.”) The highest payments were for “ultra-high” claims. To qualify the patient for such payments, the patient had to have more than 720 minutes of therapy, and it had to include a combination of physical, occupational, and speech therapy. 

The RUG levels are the following:

  • Ultra High: at least 720 minutes. Minimum two disciplines, one at least five days.
  • Very High: at least 500 minutes. Minimum one discipline, five days.
  • High: at least 325 minutes. Minimum one discipline, five days.
  • Medium: at least 150 minutes. Minimum five days.
  • Low: at least 45 minutes. Minimum three days.

So here is what frustrated CMS. There are a number of nursing homes that currently bill every patient as an ultra-high claim. In court and under appeal, they argue their patients require this care. Every patient is supposedly getting more than 720 minutes of therapy. 

A lot of those nursing homes are here in South Florida. It is an unequal spread across the country. CMS thought they were getting ripped off, and that could be true. It became a cottage industry for physical therapy providers and nursing homes to work together to increase their payments.

PDPM is called “patient-driven” because payments are now driven by the patients’ CMI, or case mix index. The CMI is based on functional scoring and not minutes of service. Nursing homes wanting to push up payments are now going to have to do something more complicated than providing minutes of service; they will have to try to push up the functional scores that drive CMI. Here is a snapshot of the new payment model:


Under PDPM, again, therapy will be paid on a per-diem basis instead of driving a higher rate based on minutes. In addition, the payment will drop for therapy the longer the patient is in the nursing home.


In conclusion, if this experiment by CMS works, look for more of the same in payment methodology from CMS. At the very least, it will take providers a while to find a new way to increase payments. Also, look for an uneven spread of the pain of regulatory change.


Comment on this article

Timothy Powell, CPA CHCP

Timothy Powell is a nationally recognized expert on regulatory matters, including the False Claims Act, Zone Program Integrity Contractor (ZPIC) audits, and U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG) compliance. He is a member of the RACmonitor editorial board and a national correspondent for Monitor Mondays.

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Related Articles

  • New Payment Models from CMS Target Kidney Disease and Radiation Therapy
    President Trump issues an executive order on kidney disease and a new payment model for radiation therapy. As reported by Dr. Ronald Hirsch on the Monitor Mondays webcast, last week the president issued an executive order on kidney disease.…
  • News Alert: CMS Proposing to Cover Acupuncture
    Coverage would include those suffering from chronic lower back pain who are also enrolled in approved studies. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) is proposing to cover acupuncture for Medicare patients who suffer from chronic lower back pain…
  • Supreme Court Decides on Judicial Deference to Agency Interpretations of Regulations
    Swing vote by Chief Justice John Roberts reflects his support of judicial precedent. On June 26 the U.S. Supreme Court issued a decision (  on how courts should handle ambiguous government regulations.  Many people, including me, expected that the case…