The One Purpose Test for Healthcare

Law professor Dershowitz tests the “one purpose test.”

During the recent impeachment trial of President Trump, Alan Dershowitz made a statement that was widely interpreted as saying that if a politician had multiple motives for a particular activity, but one of the motives was benefiting the public interest, any nefarious or improper motives are irrelevant.

As I listened to him, I hoped that no medical professionals would think that Dershowitz’s logic applied to financial relationships in the healthcare industry – because he was articulating the exact opposite of principle courts have used when interpreting the Medicare anti-kickback statute.

The statute makes it a felony to offer, pay, solicit, or receive anything of value with an intent to influence referrals. First, I’ll just mention that the law uses the term “remuneration,” but when describing the law, it is better to avoid that unnecessarily confusing word. Remuneration is defined as compensation for work. As used in the anti-kickback statute, “remuneration” is any cash or in-kind exchange, which is why I use the term “value.”

In 1995, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, which is a federal appeals court for the northeastern United States, reviewed a case in which a board-certified cardiologist had established a Holter monitor company. When the company performed an interpretation of the readings, it forwarded 40 percent of the reimbursement to the physician who had referred the patient to the company. The defendant, Dr. Greber, had testified in an earlier case, “if the doctor didn’t get his consulting fee, he wouldn’t be using our service, so the doctor got the consulting fee.” The defendant argued that since there was some work being done by the physician, as a matter of law, the payment couldn’t be an improper kickback. Much like the Dershowitz argument, he was saying “if there is any legitimate reason for the payment, the payment is legal.” The Court of Appeals rejected that argument, and stated, “we do not agree, and hold that if one purpose of the payment was to induce future referrals, the Medicare statute has been violated.”

This case created what is commonly called the “one purpose test.” Under it, no matter how many legitimate reasons there are for payment, if one of the motivations is to incentivize referrals, the transaction is a felony.

From a practical standpoint, this principle is really important. It means that one bad email or comment at a meeting can convert a legal transaction into an illegal relationship. For example, imagine that a hospital is going to set up a gainsharing or shared savings program with some orthopedic surgeons. The hospital is going to pay the orthopedic group for its time working on the program. That’s totally fine. An email explains the many legitimate reasons for the relationship. It will lower healthcare costs and improve the quality of care. But if the email ends with “and paying the doctors will encourage them to send patients to the hospital,” all of the other reasons become irrelevant.

As soon as a participant in a transaction talks about how the finances create incentives for referrals, the entire relationship is tainted.

Programming Note: Listen to David Glaser’s live reporting on Monitor Mondays, 10-10:30 a.m. EST.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

David M. Glaser, Esq.

David M. Glaser is a shareholder in Fredrikson & Byron's Health Law Group. David assists clinics, hospitals, and other health care entities negotiate the maze of healthcare regulations, providing advice about risk management, reimbursement, and business planning issues. He has considerable experience in healthcare regulation and litigation, including compliance, criminal and civil fraud investigations, and reimbursement disputes. David's goal is to explain the government's enforcement position, and to analyze whether this position is supported by the law or represents government overreaching. David is a member of the RACmonitor editorial board and is a popular guest on Monitor Mondays.

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Leveraging the CERT: A New Coding and Billing Risk Assessment Plan

Leveraging the CERT: A New Coding and Billing Risk Assessment Plan

Frank Cohen shows you how to leverage the Comprehensive Error Rate Testing Program (CERT) to create your own internal coding and billing risk assessment plan, including granular identification of risk areas and prioritizing audit tasks and functions resulting in decreased claim submission errors, reduced risk of audit-related damages, and a smoother, more efficient reimbursement process from Medicare.

April 9, 2024
2024 Observation Services Billing: How to Get It Right

2024 Observation Services Billing: How to Get It Right

Dr. Ronald Hirsch presents an essential “A to Z” review of Observation, including proper use for Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and commercial payers. He addresses the correct use of Observation in medical patients and surgical patients, and how to deal with the billing of unnecessary Observation services, professional fee billing, and more.

March 21, 2024
Top-10 Compliance Risk Areas for Hospitals & Physicians in 2024: Get Ahead of Federal Audit Targets

Top-10 Compliance Risk Areas for Hospitals & Physicians in 2024: Get Ahead of Federal Audit Targets

Explore the top-10 federal audit targets for 2024 in our webcast, “Top-10 Compliance Risk Areas for Hospitals & Physicians in 2024: Get Ahead of Federal Audit Targets,” featuring Certified Compliance Officer Michael G. Calahan, PA, MBA. Gain insights and best practices to proactively address risks, enhance compliance, and ensure financial well-being for your healthcare facility or practice. Join us for a comprehensive guide to successfully navigating the federal audit landscape.

February 22, 2024
Mastering Healthcare Refunds: Navigating Compliance with Confidence

Mastering Healthcare Refunds: Navigating Compliance with Confidence

Join healthcare attorney David Glaser, as he debunks refund myths, clarifies compliance essentials, and empowers healthcare professionals to safeguard facility finances. Uncover the secrets behind when to refund and why it matters. Don’t miss this crucial insight into strategic refund management.

February 29, 2024
2024 ICD-10-CM/PCS Coding Clinic Update Webcast Series

2024 ICD-10-CM/PCS Coding Clinic Update Webcast Series

HIM coding expert, Kay Piper, RHIA, CDIP, CCS, reviews the guidance and updates coders and CDIs on important information in each of the AHA’s 2024 ICD-10-CM/PCS Quarterly Coding Clinics in easy-to-access on-demand webcasts, available shortly after each official publication.

April 15, 2024

Trending News

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

SPRING INTO SAVINGS! Get 21% OFF during our exclusive two-day sale starting 3/21/2024. Use SPRING24 at checkout to claim this offer. Click here to learn more →